A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF PUBLIC BUILDING MAINTENANCE STRATEGIES USING MULTI-CRITERIA METHODS BASED ON CONDITION AND FUNCTION

Widsri Lai Lai Palamba; Hans Dermawan; Jureine Queenmita Caerens Lolowang; Virginia Nathaniela; Nathanael; Christohodos Evert Willijhon Marlissa

doi:10.21009/jpensil.v14i3.59150

Authors

Widsri Lai Lai Palamba Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana University
Hans Dermawan Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana University
Jureine Queenmita Caerens Lolowang Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana University
Virginia Nathaniela Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana University
Nathanael Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana Universit
Christohodos Evert Willijhon Marlissa Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering and Computer Science, Kristen Krida Wacana University

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21009/jpensil.v14i3.59150

Keywords:

Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM), Public building maintenance, Public buildings

Abstract

Public buildings serve vital functions in supporting community services, yet they often experience quality degradation due to aging, weather conditions, and limited maintenance budgets. This study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of four public building maintenance case studies, each with different functions: administrative and educational dormitory buildings, traditional markets, churches, and elementary schools. The methods employed involve various Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) approaches. The comparative findings reveal that each method yields specific and adaptive outcomes tailored to the functional characteristics of the four public building types. The key findings indicate that maintenance planning based on priority and actual damage leads to more targeted outcomes, and highlight the need for a multidimensional approach in public building maintenance policy.

References

Achuthan, K., & Murali, S. S. (2015). A comparative study of educational laboratories from cost & learning effectiveness perspective. Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 349, 143–153. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-18473-9_15

Adeswastoto, H., & Islah, M. (2018). ANALISIS_JENIS_KERUSAKAN_PADA_BANGUNAN_PERUMAHAN. Jurnal Teknik Industri Terintegrasi, 1(2), 58–68.

Agustina, M., Sahfitri, V., & Astuti, T. (2022). Analysis of Online Transportation User Satisfaction Using the Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI) and Important Performance Analysis (IPA) Methods In Palembang City. Journal of Information Systems and Informatics, 4(4). http://journal-isi.org/index.php/isi

Al-Hemoud, A. M., & Al-Asfoor, M. M. (2006). A behavior based safety approach at a Kuwait research institution. Journal of Safety Research, 37(2), 201–206.

Ariyanto, A. S. (2020). ANALISIS JENIS KERUSAKAN PADA BANGUNAN GEDUNG BERTINGKAT (Studi Kasus pada Gedung Apartemen dan Hotel Candiland Semarang) (Vol. 06, Issue 1).

Baniya, B., & Giurco, D. (2025). Net zero energy buildings and climate resilience narratives – Navigating the interplay in the building asset maintenance and management. Energy Reports, 13, 1632–1648. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.egyr.2025.01.015

Begić, H., & Krstić, H. (2024). Comprehensive review and comparative analysis of building condition assessment models. In Results in Engineering (Vol. 22). Elsevier B.V. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rineng.2024.102176

Chen, C., & Tang, L. (2019). BIM-Based Integrated Management Workflow Design for Schedule and Cost Planning of Building Fabric Maintenance. https://www.nottingham.edu.cn/en/library/documents/research-

Chen, W., Chen, K., Cheng, J. C. P., Wang, Q., & Gan, V. J. L. (2018). BIM-based Framework for Automatic Scheduling of Facility Maintenance Work Orders. Automation in Construction, 91, 15–30.

Chew, M. Y. L. (2004). Building Maintenance Technology. McGraw-Hill.

Cornelius, N., Dermawan, H., & Palamba, W. (2024). Priority Scale for the Maintenance of State Elementry School Building Components in Bogor City using the AHP-TOPSIS Method (Issue 4).

Da Silva, J. C., & De Brito, J. (2015). Inspection and diagnosis system for building facades using AHP and TOPSIS. Journal of Civil Engineering and Management, 21(2), 229–247.

Dian Anggraini, L., Deoranto, P., & Morita Ikasari, D. (2015). ANALISIS PERSEPSI KONSUMEN MENGGUNAKAN METODE IMPORTANCE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS DAN CUSTOMER SATISFACTION INDEX THE ANALYSIS OF CONSUMER PERCEPTION USED IMPORTANCE PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS METHOD AND CUSTOMER SATISFACTION INDEX (Vol. 4).

Duan, C., Li, Z., & Liu, F. (2020). Condition-based maintenance for ship pumps subject to competing risks under stochastic maintenance quality. Ocean Engineering, 218. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2020.108180

Ervianto, W. I. (2007). Studi Pemeliharaan Bangunan Gedung (Studi Kasus Gedung Kampus).

Fahruddin, F., Mangitung, D. M., & Rizal, A. (2020). Identification of Damage Level and Cost Estimate of Building Maintenance of Elementary School. MATEC Web of Conferences, 331, 01005. https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/202033101005

Hartono, W., & Saparudin, Y. (2017). SKALA PRIORITAS PEMELIHARAAN GEDUNG-GEDUNG KANTOR KECAMATAN DI KABUPATEN SUKOHARJO DENGAN METODE ANALITYCAL HIERARCHY PROCESS (AHP) (Issue 423).

Ifran Che‐Ani, A., Samsul Mohd Tazilan, A., & Afizi Kosman, K. (2011). The Development of a Condition Survey Protocol Matrix. Structural Survey, 29(1), 35–45.

Kim, S., Ge, B., & Frangopol, D. M. (2020). Optimum Target Reliability Determination for Efficient Service Life Management of Bridge Networks. Journal of Bridge Engineering, 25(10). https://doi.org/10.1061/(asce)be.1943-5592.0001623

Lavy, S., Garcia, J. A., & Dixit, M. K. (2010). Establishment of KPIs for facility performance measurement: Review of literature. Facilities, 28(9), 440–464. https://doi.org/10.1108/02632771011057189

Lolowang, J. Q. C. (2023). ANALISIS KERUSAKAN DAN ESTIMASI BIAYA PEMELIHARAAN BANGUNAN (STUDI KASUS: GEDUNG ADMINISTRASI DAN ASRAMA POLITEKNIK KELAUTAN DAN PERIKANAN BITUNG SULAWESI UTARA). Christian Krida Wacana University.

Marlissa, C. E. W., Dermawan, H., & Palamba, W. (2025). A EVALUASI KONDISI GEDUNG GEREJA DI JAKARTA BARAT DENGAN METODE CONDITION SURVEY PROTOCOL (CSP) 1. Jurnal PenSil, 14(1), 119–137. https://doi.org/10.21009/jpensil.v14i1.50182

Martilla, J. A., & James, J. C. (1977). Importance-performance analysis. In Journal of Marketing (Vol. 41).

Mawardi, E., Aulia, T. B., & Abdullah, A. (2018). KAJIAN KONSEP OPERASIONAL PEMELIHARAAN GEDUNG SMA BINA GENERASI BANGSA MEULABOH ACEH BARAT. Jurnal Teknik Sipil, 1(4), 811–822. https://doi.org/10.24815/jts.v1i4.10041

Miraglia, S. (2020). A data-driven probabilistic model for well integrity management: case study and model calibration for the Danish sector of North Sea. Journal of Structural Integrity and Maintenance, 5(2), 142–153.

Misriani, M., Hidayati, R., Bungsu Fauziah Akmal, P., Teknik Sipil Politeknik Negeri Padang, J., & Limau Manis Kota Padang, K. (2020). Perancangan Manajemen Pemeliharaan Gedung Dekanat Fakultas Kedokteran Universitas Andalas. In Jurnal Fondasi (Vol. 9).

Nabila, F., Prihantono, P., & Anisah, A. (2021). Identifikasi Bahaya dan Penilaian Risiko pada Proses Pekerjaan Pemasangan Tetap Atap Sandwich Panel. Jurnal PenSil, 10(3), 141–147. https://doi.org/10.21009/jpensil.v10i3.23242

Nugrahayu, Z., Dewantoro, & Gawei, A. B. P. (2021). Manajemen Perawatan dan Pemeliharaan Gedung, Aset dan Fasilitas di Universitas Palangka Raya. Jurnal Keilmuan Teknik Sipil, 4(2), 114–120.

Nurulita Sari, D., Soetjipto, J. W., & Arifin, S. (2022). Analisis Manajemen dan Estimasi Biaya Pemeliharaan Gedung Kantor Bupati dan Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat Daerah Kabupaten Pamekasan. Media Informasi Teknik Sipil UNIJA, 10, 83–92.

Olanrewaju, A. L., & Ooi, Y. L. (2022). Determinants of Maintenance Cost of Hospital Buildings: An Artificial Neural Network Approach. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 1067(1). https://doi.org/10.1088/1755-1315/1067/1/012083

Park, C. H., & Lim, H. (2021). A parametric approach to integer linear fractional programming: Newton’s and Hybrid-Newton methods for an optimal road maintenance problem. European Journal of Operational Research, 289(3), 1030–1039.

Ramadhani, N. A., Sasongko, W., & Kurniawan, E. B. (2022). IMPLEMENTASI AHP DALAM PENENTUAN PRIORITAS PENATAAN JALUR PEJALAN KAKI DI KAWASAN CBD BINTARO JAYA (Vol. 11, Issue 4).

Ratna Kusumastuti, D., Budi Setiawan, D., Ristanti Rahmi, D., & Rochimawati, M. (2022). Analisis Tingkat Kerusakan dan Estimasi Biaya Pemeliharaan Komponen Arsitektural pada Gedung C di Komplek Gedung Kantor Bupati Kudus (Vol. 08, Issue 1).

Saaty, T. L. (1984). THE ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS: DECISION MAKING IN COMPLEX ENVIRONMENTS.

Sabaruddin, S., Hakim, R., & Tata, A. (2024). CSI (Customer Satisfaction Index) and IPA (Importance Performance Analysis) of Speed Rum Harbort in Tidore Island City. East Asian Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, 2(12), 5245–5252. https://doi.org/10.55927/eajmr.v2i12.7693

Shohet, I. M. (2003). Building evaluation methodology for setting maintenance priorities in hospital buildings. Construction Management and Economics, 21(7), 681–692. https://doi.org/10.1080/0144619032000115562

Tzeng, G.-H., & Chang, H.-F. (2011). Journal of Technology Management & Innovation 1 National Visiting Professor, Institute of Management of Technology. In J. Technol. Manag. Innov (Vol. 6, Issue 3). http://www.jotmi.org

Virginia Nathaniela. (2024). Evaluasi Kegiatan Pemeliharaan dan Perawatan Gedung Pasar di Jakarta Utara. Christian Krida Wacana University.

Wang, K. C., Almassy, R., Wei, H. H., & Shohet, I. M. (2022). Integrated Building Maintenance and Safety Framework: Educational and Public Facilities Case Study. Buildings, 12(6). https://doi.org/10.3390/buildings12060770

Wiyanto, H., & Yesaya, A. (2022). PENENTUAN NILAI KONDISI BANGUNAN GEDUNG BERDASARKAN METODE MATRIKS CONDITION SURVEY PROTOCOL 1 (CSP 1). In JMTS: Jurnal Mitra Teknik Sipil (Vol. 5, Issue 3).

Wu, Y., Maravelias, C. T., Wenzel, M. J., ElBsat, M. N., & Turney, R. T. (2021). Predictive maintenance scheduling optimization of building heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems. Energy and Buildings, 231(110487)